The Best Pepperoni Pizza In NYC

Best in Town (formerly known as Best of the Best) is BACK for a limited-run season 3. In this episode, Herrine Ro and Erin Kommor search New York City to find the best pepperoni pizza. They visit Prince Street Pizza to try the Spicy Spring, Rubirosa to eat the Tie Dye Roni Pie, and Emily to try two different versions of their pepperoni pizza, The Colony. In the end, they declare which place is the best in town.

Editor’s Note: Insider visited these restaurants in December 2019. The restaurants are all currently closed to dine-in service due to the ongoing pandemic, but have various takeout and delivery options.